When the Celtic Tiger was reduced to mews

Posted On Friday, Dec 10, 2010

Despair! That’s the one overpowering feeling that hits me as I follow the Irish tale of gloom. Every testimony of a young professional looking at migrating for better (actually, just about any) job opportunities is a story of survival. What can a nation that is experiencing such a drain of its future hope for?

At the bailout press conference you could almost feel the anger, confusion and sense of loss of the Irish people present there. Prime Minister Brian Cowen couldn`t tell his people how much the bailout would be, how it would be drawn down, nor how long it would take to get Ireland back on track.

The only thing he could tell them though was that he was not to blame for the current situation.

So who is to blame? Is it the Irish people, who are paying with their jobs, livelihoods, and futures? – Is there an answer to who caused the Celtic Tiger to be reduced to mews?

From the Tiger to the Dodo

An estimated deficit of 32.5% of GDP for 2010!

Total Government debt at 80% of GDP!


Ireland is still badly hit despite efforts to prop up its insolvent banking system.

However, Ireland’s underlying problems are different from those of Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain (commonly referred to as PIIGS, with the inclusion of Ireland). The root cause of the financial crisis in these nations was unsustainable welfare spending which led to the creation of high and structural public deficits. Uncompetitive factor markets added another blow to their economic woes. These nations opted for deficit spending to artificially increase living standards; used deficits to finance the unemployed, public employees, and pensioners, which in turn served to sustain inflexible labour markets.

Such irresponsible economics was only possible because it was taken for granted that if the situation worsened (as it eventually did), the other Euro nations would step in to prevent the fall of the Euro by bailing these governments out.

However, Ireland was different. The Irish problems were created, not by an excessive welfare system, but by socializing the losses of a privileged banking system.

With one of the lowest corporate tax rates in the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) - 12.5% - Ireland attracted foreign banks and businesses looking for new territories to expand. As a consequence, Ireland`s banking sector boomed. During the good years, credit expansion policies and government backing ensured that the banking sector saw growing profits. However, with time, these credit expansion policies presented Ireland with a should-have-been-expected problem - a housing bubble, which caused Irish banks substantial losses and even insolvency when the bubble finally burst.

Following up on this fiasco, the Irish government guaranteed all Irish bank liabilities, thus socializing the banking industry’s losses.


Here’s an interesting fact:

The Irish banks are in trouble - If they go down, their lenders will go down too - The lenders to the Irish banks happen to be major banks of other European countries - Thus, the major banks of other European countries are in trouble too - Hence, the pressure on the European Union to bailout Ireland.

The decision was never Ireland’s to make

Why not leave Ireland to fight its own battle, you ask? Well, simply because, this is not Ireland’s problem alone, it has the entire Euro-zone muddled up in it, and nations are afraid that the instability will spread and create a domino effect where one nation goes down after another.

Consider this -

Euro-zone governments believed that bailing out Ireland would take the pressure off Portugal. Now Portugal is important because they have large investments from Spanish banks.

Hence, if Portugal were to fall, the Spanish banking system would fall along with it.

At this brink, the situation would be uncontrollable. And thus, the pressure on Ireland to accept the bailout.

There are ofcourse other reasons, for instance, the fact that English, French, and German banks had invested important sums in Ireland.

Ironically Ireland’s losses wielded enough influence to eat up the capital of European banks and bring down the whole European banking system and its allies - European Governments.


The Irish population was strongly opposed to this bailout. But yet, the government persisted.

How could the Irish government be "convinced" to accept a bailout not supported by its own people? And this, despite claiming to be funded until well into 2011?

A few theories -

Since the crisis, Irish banks have depended on monetary support from the European Central Bank. Without this support, Irish banks would probably go bankrupt, which would spell disaster for the Irish government. The ECB refused to continue its support, when Ireland’s government resisted the bailout earlier on.

To add to this, Germany threatened to withdraw its guarantees for over-indebted euro governments, which would ensure that these governments fail given soaring interest rates. This has put Germany in a commanding position leaving no option for other nations.


Someone has to pay the price

The Irish bailout actually weakens the other countries. Governments of the Euro-zone will have to pay higher interest rates for their own debts due to the additional burden caused by the loans to Ireland. Post the bailout announcement, the yields of even German government bonds have increased.

The plight of embattled countries is even worse - not only do they have to repair public finances and fix banks, but they also need to simultaneously restore competitiveness and growth.

Are these bailout mechanisms which will eventually be accompanied by money printing a real solution? Not really. In fact it only increases the problem at hand over the long term. You cannot solve a debt problem by issuing more debt.

Policy makers in the Euro region now face a stark choice: "Press forward with a de facto fiscal union", or, "Confront the risk of defaults and the unravelling of the Euro-zone."

The joke called - Policymaking
The Irish program solves nothing. The international loan will need Ireland to pay an interest rate of 5.8%, in inclusion to the principal repayment that shall commence after a couple of years. This would mean that Ireland will be transferring nearly 10% of its national income as reparations to the bondholders, year after year.

Not accepting the bailout was probably the most correct decision to make for Ireland. Because of the bailout ordinary taxpayers are now responsible to cover bank losses. The bailout money will mainly serve to sustain the living standards of bankers, rather than those of the people of Ireland. Do you remember Germany’s experience while preparing for World War I reparations? A similar situation here, which is not politically sustainable at all - a populist backlash is a likely possibility.

Policymakers are not helping the situation in any way, simply prolonging the problems and allowing them to grow bigger by the day. Are there any correction steps taken? Well, not really. In fact they are being inflated into bigger problems for the future.

What a flaw in policymaking! Till the time that such a mockery of economics is existent and allowed, there seems to be only one true form of money - Gold. With the experience of historically keeping value, it probably makes most sense to back your portfolio with gold in times of such reckless money creation. Because, who knows when the next tiger would be poached...

Click here to invest in the Quantum Gold Fund ETF

Click Here for a list of some prominent online brokers through whom you may purchase the Quantum Gold Fund.



The views expressed in this article are the personal views of the Fund Manager of Quantum Gold Fund. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. This information is meant for general reading purpose only and is not meant to serve as a professional guide/investment advice for the readers. This article has been prepared on the basis of publicly available information, internally developed data and other sources believed to be reliable. Readers are advised to seek independent professional advice and arrive at an informed investment decision before making any investments.

Investment Objective: Quantum Gold Fund’s (QGF) investment objective is to generate returns that are in line with the performance of gold and gold related instruments, subject to tracking errors. However, investment in gold related instruments will be made if and when SEBI permits mutual funds to invest in gold related instruments. The Scheme is designed to provide returns that before expenses, closely correspond to the returns provided by gold. Asset Allocation: QGF will primarily invest in physical gold and if allowed under SEBI Regulations, also in gold related securities including derivatives, and the scheme may invest in Money Market Instruments, short term corporate debt securities,CBLO and units of Debt and Liquid Schemes of Mutual Funds to meet liquidity needs. Terms of Issue: QGF is an open-ended Gold Exchange Traded Fund. Each unit of QGF will be approximately equal to the price of half (1/2) gram of Gold. Units will be issued at NAV based prices. On an ongoing basis direct purchases from the Fund would be restricted to only Authorised Participants and Eligible Investors. Units of QGF can be bought /sold like any other stock on the National Stock Exchange of India Ltd (NSE) or on any other stock exchanges where it is listed. Entry Load: N.A. Exit Load: Nil in case of Authorised Participants; 0.5% in case of Eligible Investors. Risk Factors: All Mutual Funds and securities investments are subject to market risks including uncertainty of dividend distributions and the NAV of the schemes may go up or down depending upon the factors and forces affecting the gold and securities markets and there is no assurance or guarantee that the objectives of the scheme will be achieved. Quantum Gold Fund, is the name of the scheme and does not in any manner indicate either the quality of the Scheme, its future prospects or returns. Scheme Specific Risk: The QGF’s NAV will react to the Gold price movements. The Investor may lose money over short or long period due to fluctuation in Scheme’s NAV in response to factors such as economic and political developments, changes in interest rates and perceived trends in bullion prices, market movement and over longer periods during market downturns. Trading volumes, settlement periods and transfer procedures may restrict the liquidity of these investments of the QGF. It is to be distinctly understood that the permission given by NSE should not in any way be deemed or construed that the Scheme Information Document for QGF has been cleared or approved by NSE nor does it certify the correctness or completeness of any of the contents of the said Scheme Information Document. The investors are advised to refer to the Scheme Information Document of QGF for full text of the ‘Disclaimer Clause of NSE’. Statutory Details: Quantum Mutual Fund (Fund) has been constituted as a Trust under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882.Sponsors: Quantum Advisors Private Limited. (Liability of Sponsor limited to Rs. 1,00,000/-)Trustee: Quantum Trustee Company Private Limited. Investment Manager: Quantum Asset Management Company Private Limited (AMC). The Sponsor, Trustee and the Investment Manager are incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956..The past performance of the Sponsor / AMC/ Fund has no bearing on the expected performance of the scheme. Mutual Funds investments are subject to market risks. Please read the Scheme Information Document(s) / Key Information Memorandum(s) / Statement of Additional Information / Addendums carefully before investing. Scheme Information Document(s) /Key Information Memorandum(s)/ Statement of Additional Information can be obtained at any of our Investor Service Centers or at the office of the AMC 505, Regent Chambers, 5th Floor, Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400 021 or on AMC website www.QuantumAMC.Com / www.QuantumMF.com

View All

Get In Touch

Take small steps to achieve big dreams! Start your investment journey today!

@@[email protected]@